Q:

Are two-way radios just a hiking gimmick?

I've seen quite a few hikers with two-way radios on the trail. What's your take: recreational gimmick or worthwhile piece of equipment? Our family of four hikes together a fair amount, so I can see their worth. But, then again, does trail etiquette mean this is akin to using a cell phone on the bus? Philip Burlington, Vermont

Oct 15, 2003
Outside
Outside Magazine
A: That's a good question. Since their introduction six or seven years ago, FRS-band radios (the FRS stands for Family Radio Service) have become ubiquitous on ski slopes and on some trails. These little things do work pretty well. Most have multiple channels, plus "scramblers" that allow several parties to be on the same channel and not overhear one another.

FRS-band radios are advertised as having a two-mile range. Slightly more powerful GMRS (General Mobile Radio Service) units have a range of up to five miles. But, for GMRS radios you need an FCC license. Some portable radios have both FRS and GMRS bands, though. An example: Motorola's Talkabout T5720 ($50 per pair; www.rei.com).

Anyway, that's all background chatter. Do they work on a trail? Within certain pretty tight limits, yes, but remember the two-mile range pertains to ideal conditions. Remember, too, that radios such as these are line-of-sight devices. If one radio can't "see" the other—meaning there's a mountain or rock ridge in the way—then they can't communicate. Dense stands of trees or large bodies of water may also interfere with radio signals. When I was active in mountain rescue, we had fits in the woods even with our very powerful military-style two-way radios, which under perfect conditions had ranges of many, many miles.

So, my sense is that the working range for these radios on the trail is somewhere between a quarter and half mile, and very rarely a mile or more. And, it's certainly less if one party turns a corner around a hillside.

Still, for $50 you might well get some use out of these things. I'd say they're great if, for instance, Party A has left camp to go fishing at a nearby lake, and Party B wants to call Party A back to camp for supper. Or, if Party A is hiking up a nearby hill that can be seen from camp, and wants to radio their progress.

I'm very reluctant to recommend these things as "safety" devices, as in, "If you get hurt or lost, just radio us." Because the odds are very high that when you most need these to work, they won't.

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!