Q:

Are trail runners too flimsy to wear on an approach climb?

I climbing Rainier this July and instead of wearing my normal hiking boots up to Cp Muir, I was wondering if you thought a pair of trail-running shoes would work until we have to switch to plastic boots? What would be some good options for lightweight shoes that would still give you good support when wearing a pack? Mike Columbus, Ohio

Jun 9, 2004
Outside
Outside Magazine

Nagevi XCR

A: It's really a matter of personal choice. Certainly, it makes sense from an energy standpoint to carry your plastics or heavy leather boots to Mount Rainier's Camp Muir, at 10,080 feet. The saying goes that one pound on your feet is like five on your back, or some such, so you'll hike quicker and feel better with light shoes on your feet and heavy ones in the pack.

Besides, given the weather this year, you're apt to be on dry trail well past the 7,000-foot mark, certainly as far as Pebble Creek, a popular place to stop for a drink and a key landmark between Muir and the Paradise Inn area (as you know, the start point for the climb proper). There is an issue of ankle stability with what is apt to be a large load, but that's for you to decide. If you think you'll be OK with light shoes, then go for it. The trail up to the year-round snowline is broad and smooth, with cut-stone stairs in many places. On a warm day you may even be happy wearing light shoes all the way to 10,000 feet, but if it's cold and blustery, or even raining, then you may opt to don the plastics.

As for which shoes, I'd say any low-cut day hiker would suffice. I would, however, avoid a trail runner, because the soft midsoles may lead to bruised feet. Get a light hiker that's a cut-down version of a true boot. The Garmont Nagevi XCR ($115; www.garmontusa.com) has proven to be an extremely popular choice in this category. It even has a Gore-Tex bootie, although that's pretty useless the instant you overtop them when hopping a stream. But they're grippy and stable, and may get you all the way to Muir. The Asolo Axis ($85; www.asolo.com) is another good low-top hiker, with Vibram soles for good grip. And check out the Five Ten Via Ferrata ($115; www.fiveten.com), which is both waterproof and has a pretty stiff midsole.

Hope you have a great climb! If you haven't been up Rainier before, it's a wonderful experience. Well, except for the long, baking slog up the Muir Snowfield, the midnight start, and that long, awful, mind-numbing descent...

Check out more über-footwear in Outside's 2004 Buyer's Guide

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!