Q:

Can a soft shell provide heavy-duty warmth?

I love the athletic look of soft shells and would love to buy one. The only problem is I've heard they're just that: shells, meant more for layering than for providing a single layer of protection. In your opinion, are there any soft shells that can provide both heavy-duty warmth and stand up to the rain and snow? I'll use this shell more for "getting around town" than I would for aerobic activities, so I want something that would keep me very warm in cold temperatures. Megan Spokane, Washington

Mar 24, 2004
Outside
Outside Magazine

One Jacket

A: I've said it before and I'll say it again: I don't think any product line out there causes quite as much confusion as the "soft-shell" category. Seeing as even the manufacturers can't always agree on what they mean, I suppose that's not surprising.

I'll give you my take, but first some theory. If you collected a pile of clothing with, say, a waterproof shell, a fleece jacket, and maybe a heavy insulating jacket such as a down parka, and then figured out what percentage of your outdoor time was spent wearing each one, you might find something like this: fleece jacket, worn 40 percent of the time; waterproof shell, 20 percent; fleece and shell, 30 percent; down jacket, 10 percent of the time. (I'm also assuming that you start with a light- or medium-weight base layer).

So you see, your clothing in some cases spends more time on the hanger or in a pack than on you. A soft shell is supposed to be more like a 60-percent player—in cool and damp weather, it replaces the fleece and shell by doing a pretty good job of keeping you warm and a pretty good job of keeping you dry. And it does so with less bulk than the fleece and better breathability than the waterproof shell.

A good example in this category: REI's One Jacket ($198; www.rei.com). Made with Polartec Power Shield, it can be worn skiing, hiking, biking, even around town—basically, any time you want some protection from wind and light rain, need some insulation, but don't want to overheat. It's a very useful piece. The Arc'Teryx Gamma SV ($250; ww.arcteryx.com) is very similar—same material, though with slightly more technical cut and features, including hand-warmer pockets. I use a very similar jacket when bicycling in cold weather—I just throw it over a light T-shirt and I'm off. I have a One as well, and use that for hiking and hanging out around town.

What can get a little confusing is that some soft shells are really more of a light rain shell. That would include Cloudveil's Prospector Jacket ($135; www.cloudveil.com). It's meant to be worn like the One in some cases, but added to a fleece underlayer for more warmth in others.

Either way, I will say that none of these jackets is really a big-time insulating piece. Something like the One or Gamma would be fine for those cold days when you're walking around town, popping in and out of stores, that sort of thing. But standing at a cold bus stop for 30 minutes or sitting in the stands at a football game on a cold November night? Probably not warm enough. For that, alas, you're back to some of the old standbys like the fleece/shell combo or a serious insulator such as a down jacket.

Filed To: Soft Shell

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!