Yuck. I hate plastic boots on Rainier, too. So what was the worst part, Daytonthose final two miles on the way down when you were hot, exhausted, footsore, and thigh-sore, yet able to see the oh-so-seemingly-close Paradise Lodge? Thats the part I hate, I will tell you that.
There are so many very good choices these days. Really, for what you are talking about, Scarpas Escape ($225) is fine. These are a heavy (but not heavy," if you get my drift) backpacking boot, suitable for crampons, with a Gore-Tex bootie, and very comfortable. Theyre not insulated, so just be sure to have some good wool socks. For a summer Rainier trip, they are perfectly fine. I also like Vasques Alpine Light GTX ($235), which are a little heavier but still nothing to compare to plastics.
Or, for something close to plastics for heft but still comfortable, try Asolos Expert GV GTX ($285). They have tough synthetic/leather uppers, beefy midsoles, and plenty of stability for use on steeper terrain with crampons. Ill be honest, ideally you see the mountain every day (as I do, if its clear), read the National Weather Service forecast, and then make an educated guess as to what to wear. That would let me go with a lighter boot such as the Escape, knowing I could finesse colder weather with good socks and gaiters. But for more of a take-whatever-comes boot, probably go with the Asolo.
Anyway, have fun. Go for early July, when the weather is better. And why the hell are you doing it again? Dont you have it out of your system yet?
The 2008 Summer Outside Buyers Guide is now online. From riding to trail-running to camping, get reviews of nearly 400 gear must-haves.