Q:

Is there such thing as a lightweight four-season tent?

I’m in the market for a new two-person four-season tent that will keep me dry in snowy conditions but won’t weight me down too much while snowshoeing. Any recommendations? Missy Portland, Maine

Dec 5, 2006
Outside
Outside Magazine
Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 tent

Trango 2 tent

A:

Technology has done wondrous things in the outdoor-gear world in recent years, but one nut remains fairly tough to crack: a lightweight four-season tent. The reasons for that are varied. Tents that can stand up to wind, heavy snow-loads, and cold temperatures need more poles and material than their summer-friendly tent kin. Add-ons such as pole-supported vestibules are exceedingly useful things if you’re snow-bound for even a day or two, but those add weight as well. And sometimes four-season tents are simply a little larger to accommodate fat cold-weather sleeping bags and all the extra gear snow campers tend to drag into the tent.

What you usually end up with is a tent such as the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 ($450; www.mountainhardwear.com). It’s an excellent tent, with a spacious interior, rugged design, fully waterproof bathtub floor, pole-supported vestibule, and more. You’ll be very happy sitting out a snowstorm in a Trango 2. You might be less happy, however, carrying all ten pounds of it.

Marmot’s Thor ($469; www.marmot.com) is a little leaner—just over eight pounds—and has similar features such as the pole-supported vestibule. It’s a little smaller, with 38 square feet as opposed to the Trango’s 41. But that’s still a pretty roomy two-person tent. Lots of summer tents have around 30 square feet and claim space for two.

Other options? You could go radical, for instance. The Black Diamond Lighthouse ($369; www.bdel.com), uses a single-wall, nearly waterproof design that employs Epic Nextec fabric. It’ll easily shed snow and is tough enough to take big wind and snow loads. And (drum roll) it weighs around three pounds. But life is full of tradeoffs. For one, single-wall tents are inherently colder than double-walls such as the Trango or Thor because they lack that air space between the fly and canopy. Two, the Lighthouse has no vestibule, unless you buy the optional one from Black Diamond. But that’s another $139, plus it adds another pound-plus. Or, try the MSR Twin Peaks ($189; www.msrcorp.com). It’s actually only half a tent, sort of a pole-supported tarp. You dig out a below-grade shelter for your sleeping bags, pitch the Twin Peaks over that, then pile snow along the base of the tent. An almost instant igloo. And it weighs less than two pounds.

On the bargain front, REI Mountain 2 holds two people, stands up to lousy weather, weighs a not-unreasonable nine pounds, and costs only $269.

Lastly, you can try a tent that eschews American design, such as the Hilleberg Jannu ($595; www.hilleberg.com). It’s a true all-season tent that uses some innovative design tricks (such as a canopy and fly that are pre-connected for faster setup) and super-light materials to yield a strong tent that sleeps two and weighs about six pounds, three ounces. The one tradeoff here, besides the fairly harsh price, is that the Jannu’s vestibule is staked out, not pole-supported. That may or may not make a difference, as it largely precludes using the vestibule for a cooking space during long periods of bad weather. But it’s an excellent tent.

Get more advice from the Gear Guy as he picks this season’s top gifts in Away.com’s Holiday Gift Guide. You’ll probably find a few things to put on your own wish list, too.

Filed To: Tents

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!