Q:

Should I use a water filter or a water purifier on backpacking trips?

Hi, I want to purchase a water filter or water purifier to turn my day hikes into some overnight trips. I have been doing a lot of research but can't seem to figure out which one I need. I'll primarily be hiking in the Northeast and only in North erica, so is there a need for an actual water "purifier"? Thanks in advance. Kane Red Bank, NJ

Sep 10, 2009
Outside
Outside Magazine

The HyperFlow Microfilter

A:

That’s an interesting question, Kane. Generally, I think water filters are fine for North America. But there are indications that purifiers are in order, especially in areas that get a lot of human use.

That doesn’t mean you have to do a lot of fancy stuff. Try MSR's newish, easy-to-use HyperFlow Microfilter ($100), which lets you filter more than two quarts a minute yet still catch all those nasty cryptosporidia and giardia thingies. Or try the Katadyn Hiker Pro ($80), a proven design that’s easy to use, very effective, and can be overhauled in the field as needed.

Either of those would be fine for most hikes. I have no idea where the line is, but on certain hikes—lots of hikers around, fairly still water, would be my trigger—you can do some after-the-fact purifying. MSR’s Sweetwater Purifier ($10/two fluid ounces) is a chlorine-based solution that is added to filtered water. It does have some impact on water flavor, but it can be hidden with powered Gatorade or other mixes. And it isn’t really that bad.

Anyway, water purifying is largely a two-step process, so it’s no big deal to take the Sweetwater solution along as well as a filter. The exception is yet another MSR product, the MSR MIOX ($140). It uses an electrical charge (it requires batteries) and salt to make a solution that kills any bad stuff in water. It is not instant—cryptosporidia requires four hours of time before it’s official dead. Which means that you will ALWAYS wait four hours if you want to be “sure." But the MIOX is compact, easy to use, and great for filtering large quantities of water, so there is that.

Filed To: Water Treatment

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!