Q:

The temperature ratings on sleeping bags confuse me. Can you help?

I?m looking to invest in a sleeping bag and want to know how to choose the proper temperature rating. You?ve said that it must be rated ten degrees warmer than the coldest temperatures expected. Why is that? And is that in degrees Celsius? Also, I will be purchasing a tent, so how much do I rely on the tent and how much on the sleeping bag? Is the tent only for the wind and rain, or can it be really warmer? Vladimir Tokyo, Japan

Dec 23, 2009
Outside
Outside Magazine
A:

Hey, Vladimir. How are things in Tokyo?

I’m not sure I "choose" temperature ratings so much as trust what I am given by (I hope) trustworthy manufacturers, then factor in my own variables. I do like the "ten-degree rule" (meaning, if you expect to see 30 degrees F, get a bag rated to 20) due to the idea that you might be camping when you are wet, tired, calorie-drained, and not really capable of keeping up with the temperature drop. In some cases, you also can REVERSE that rule—if you expect 30, buy a bag at 40 and use the clothes you carry to make up the difference.

Anyway…as I infer in the paragraph above, I am assuming Fahrenheit, not Celsius, as U.S. manufacturers use that scale. If Celsius, simply take the rated temp and add or subtract five degrees Celsius, and you get to the same place.

The question of "what does a tent add?" is a difficult one. It does add something, to be sure. It keeps the wind out, captures a little bit of body heat, and so on. I have never been camping in cold weather and kept a thermometer inside the tent, then put one outside and compared the two—but I should have by now. I’ll estimate that if it’s 32 degrees (0 Celsius) outside, it’s probably at least five degrees Fahrenheit warmer inside (two or three degrees Celsius). So you can factor that in, too.

Trouble is, there are just so many variables that hard rules are, well, hard to make. Some people sleep "warm," some do not. A good sleeping pad makes a big difference, as the ground is cold. How much you wear when turning in also makes a difference. And there is your physical condition when you go to bed. So, a little trial and error might be in order.

Filed To: Sleeping Bags

More at Outside

Not Now

Need a Gear Fix?

Open email. Get latest gear. Repeat.

Thank you!