Which vitamin D supplements should I be using?
Vitamin D is like Tiger Woodsit just can't stay out of the news.
Hardly a week went by this spring without a study spotlighting some powerful new health benefit of the sunshine vitamin: that it boosts the immune system, lowers the risk of a battery of cancers, protects our hearts,
While humans evolved to quickly get megadoses of vitamin D from sunlight, our indoor jobs, diligent use of sunscreen, and legitimate concerns about skin damage from sun exposure have caused a shortage on an epidemic scale. Approximately 77 percent of the U.S. population has "insufficient" levels of vitamin D, according to a study last year in the Archives of Internal Medicine. That includes people living in sunny climates and athletes who spend lots of time outside. In a 2007 study of 20 distance runners in fair-weather Baton Rouge, Louisiana, 40 percent were short on D.
"Getting adequate vitamin D is probably more important than any other nutrition recommendation we have made for years, including whether to reduce saturated fat or salt intake," says Dr. Robert Heaney, a researcher at Nebraska's Creighton University and one of the country's leading vitamin D experts. "We won't know the true burden of chronic disease until we eradicate vitamin D deficiency."
Our diet isn't helping much. Even in fortified foods like milk, there's just not enough vitamin D to provide what many experts now say we needbetween 1,000 and 2,000 international units (IU) per day.
The fastest and easiest way to get more Dbriefly dousing the body with UVB lightis also the most controversial. After all, those are the same cancer-causing, skin-aging rays that make dermatologists shudder, and only a few experts, like endocrinologist and researcher Michael Holick, author of The Vitamin D Solution , are willing to recommend it. "You can get five to 15 minutes of unfiltered sun two to three times weekly, depending on your skin type and the time of day," Holick says. "Your arms and legs should be exposed, but you can still protect your face."
That statement doesn't sit well with the American Academy of Dermatology, which, while recognizing the widespread shortage of vitamin D in the U.S., insists that no amount of unfiltered sun exposure is safe. One in five Americans will develop skin cancer during their lifetimes, mostly from unfiltered UV rays.
A far safer bet is to take a supplement, like a multivitamin or single-nutrient vitamin D pillbut even here the experts are in disagreement. Many nutritionists believe that the FDA's daily recommended intake of 400 IU for adults up to age 50which you'll see on products' nutrition labelsis woefully outdated. Groups like the Skin Cancer Foundation and many vitamin D researchers agree you need at least 1,000 IU daily. The National Institutes of Health says that 2,000 IU is the upper limit of what's healthy.
Good luck getting that dose from your food. A seven-ounce fillet of wild salmon may give you 1,400 IU, but you should eat no more than 12 ounces a week due to mercury concerns. An eight-ounce glass of vitamin Dfortified milk comes in at a surprisingly low 100 IU.Since you're active and probably in the sun more than most people, you're likely getting some solar vitamin D, even if you're slathering up: A few UVB rays slip through sunscreen,no matter how frequently it's applied. But don't count on that being enough. The most reliable way to see if you're coming up short is to get your blood levels tested (see next page) and adjust your supplements accordingly.
"We're not saying that you should get vitamin D from sunlight, but don't expect to obtain it from food," Heaney says. "And if you're not going to obtain vitamin D from either, you must take supplements."