Performance Insiders

Monday, September 05, 2011 24

Q: What are the most overrated exercises?

It seems like most people I see in the gym use the same exercises. Which exercises work and which moves are overrated?

By: Question from: The Editors, Santa Fe, New Mexico

Photo By: LULULEMON ATHLETICA/FLICKR

A:

Doing the same workout over and over again isn’t just boring, it’s ineffective. When you repeat the same movements time after time, your body adapts, which limits your results. You can also develop strength imbalances and postural issues over time if you don’t mix things up. To get the most out of your workout, swap out some of your usual moves with new ones. Here are three to get you started: 

Overrated: Crunches
The crunch places unnecessary strain on your back, and it only targets the rectus abdominis.

Do This Instead: The Running Plank
The running plank trains your entire pillar—your shoulders, torso, and hips—while stabilizing your spine and improving posture to help you look and perform better. To do it, start in a push-up position with your hands beneath your shoulders and feet shoulder-width apart. Keeping your hips and torso still, draw one knee toward your chest. Return to the starting position and repeat with the opposite leg. (Click here to watch the video.)

Overrated: Seated Machine Chest Press
When performing the seated machine chest press, your body has to follow a fixed path. This limits the range of motion in which you can build muscle and neglects important stabilizing muscles of your shoulders. Think about it this way: When the machine provides the stability, your body doesn’t have to.

Do This Instead: 1 Arm Bench Press
The 1 Arm Bench Press places the weight on one side of your body, forcing you to stabilize your body using your core. You’ll develop core strength and upper-body power that transfer to everyday activities and the sports field. To do it, lie face-up on a bench with your hips just off the edge of the bench. Hold a dumbbell at your shoulder in one hand and the bench behind your head with your other hand. Keeping your hips in line with your shoulders, press the weight over your chest and then lower it to your shoulder. Complete the set on one side, and repeat with the opposite arm. (Click here to watch the video.)

Overrated: Knee Extension
Knee extensions focus solely on your quads, but don’t help build strength and stability throughout the rest of your lower body.

Do This Instead: Split Squat with Back Foot Up
You’ll get a greater total-body workout with the Split Squat with Back Foot Up. This move benefits your quads, hamstrings, and glutes while building single-leg strength and stability to boost your performance. Here’s how to do it: Stand tall in a split stance holding a pair of dumbbells with your weight primarily on your front foot and your back foot elevated on a bench. Lower your hips toward the ground by bending your front knee. Push through your front leg to return to the starting position. Finish your set on one side, and then repeat with the opposite leg forward. (Click here to watch the video.)

 

Related Articles
The Best Core Exercise You’re Not Doing
Train Movements, Not Muscles

How Much Weight Should I Lift?

Author's Bio

Kevin Elsey

As director of the Performance Innovation Team at Athletes’ Performance, Kevin Elsey, M.Ed., will help you make your training more efficient and effective. Ask him how to save time in the gym and get better results. Check out his articles at coreperformance.com.

More at Outside

Comments

24
Walt

All good. You could have listed 10 more useless exercises from the standard gym repertoire.

Flag This
Sean

Knee extensions are not just ineffective (They don't train the parts of your quads that help you run) they will also DESTROY YOUR KNEES. Never do knee extensions.

Flag This
John

Is it true that running backwards is more efficient than forward as world record holder, Brian Mclean, demonstrated in Atlanta half marathon in March? http://www.vistaprint.com/vp/gateway.aspx?s=5462298015&preurl=%2fshare-design.aspx%3fdoc_id%3d2248230156%26shopper_id%3dFPLDEWTFQQJPO56OTI64GZOELW33H3HM%26xnav%3dsharesource_4

Flag This
Michelle

Yes. Brian Mclean ran forward and backwards at 89 mins each.

Flag This
Mike

I understand that it is the same motion, but isn't running backwards more demanding than forward running, muscularly speaking????

Flag This
Kevin

Since running backwards is an identical movement, it serves to demonstrate muscle usage is not dependant upon resistance timing, just resistance magnitude. Meaning that if you train your muscles properly, you can do anything. I guess this means running forward is the most overrated exercise. We should all run backward like Brian

Flag This
Anonymous

I get it. When you run backwards, you need to run in front someone for the entire race. Cool pic of Brian and Laurie. http://www.vistaprint.com/vp/gateway.aspx?s=5462298015&preurl=%2fshare-design.aspx%3fdoc_id%3d2248230156%26shopper_id%3dFPLDEWTFQQJPO56OTI64GZOELW33H3HM%26xnav%3dsharesource_4

Flag This
John

He uses a biking mirror when he goes on long backwards runs alone. He often spins for an entire run, like tennis training runs.

Flag This
Michelle

Yeah, Brian is pretty famous in Cincinnati, Atlanta, and New York for his backwards running. It all originated with the Atlanta Track Monkeys and Atlanta Track Club. s

Flag This
Michelle

Yeah, Brian is pretty famous in Cincinnati, Atlanta, and New York for his backwards running. It all originated with the Atlanta Track Monkeys and Atlanta Track Club. s

Flag This
Kevin

Too bad that neither of them made the Olympic team!

Flag This
Preston

Brian Mclean has a great chance at making the 2013 Masters Olympic Team.

Flag This
Kevin

That's an amazing picture! http://www.vistaprint.com/vp/gateway.aspx?s=5462298015&preurl=%2fshare-design.aspx%3fdoc_id%3d2248230156%26shopper_id%3dFPLDEWTFQQJPO56OTI64GZOELW33H3HM%26xnav%3dsharesource_4

Flag This
Anonymous

89:56 for 13.1 backwards is pretty impressive especially for 42 year old.

Flag This
Anonymous

89:56 for 13.1 backwards is pretty impressive especially for 42 year old.

Flag This
Michelle

To be precise Brian Mclean ran: 13.5 forward in 1:29:29 12.7 backwards 1:29:56 thus not totally equal distance and pace

Flag This
Michelle

Chip time shows 1:29:05 forward for Brian Mclean

Flag This
Mike

Clearly the most overrated exercise is running forward.

Flag This
Preston

Brian Mclean coaches youth runners in Atlanta. His daughter holds the US cross country record for 2K for 5 and under.

Flag This
Preston

Brian Mclean coaches youth runners in Atlanta. His daughter holds the US cross country record for 2K for 5 and under.

Flag This
James LeRoy

Yes. He is amazing. He went by me backwards at a rediculous pace, around 6:40/mile or SO.

Flag This
James LeRoy

Yes. He is amazing. He went by me backwards at a rediculous pace, around 6:40/mile or SO.

Flag This
Bradley Roper

Nice pic of Brian and Laurie: http://www.vistaprint.com/vp/gateway.aspx?s=5462298015&preurl=%2fshare-design.aspx%3fdoc_id%3d2248230156%26shopper_id%3dFPLDEWTFQQJPO56OTI64GZOELW33H3HM%26xnav%3dsharesource_4

Flag This
Anonymous

I am sorry. Brian Mclean was 41 when he ran this race.

Flag This

Post Comment

Current Issue Outside Magazine

Subscribe and get a great deal! 2 FREE Buyer's Guides plus a FREE GoLite Sport Bottle. Monthly delivery of Outside - your ultimate resource for today's active lifestyle. All that and BIG SAVINGS!

Free Newsletter

Get our e-mail dispatch, with Outside articles & online exclusives, delivered to your inbox each week.

Ask a Question

Our gear experts await your outdoor-gear-related questions. Go ahead, ask them anything.

* We might edit your question for length or clarity. If it's not about gear, we'll just ignore it.