A:Dean, Id like to direct your attention to a photo that appeared in May in the Anchorage Daily News. It depicts one Nadia Cuadrado , a 29-year-old woman from Spain who took a crack at Denali in mid-May. She summited, but in the process froze her feet. In the photo, you can see her purple toesmost of which she likely will lose.
So, sure, wear your Montrail ICE 9 boots. And then ask yourself, do you value your toes? Because the ICE 9s ($350 when new, but now discontinued) are fine boots, but theyre really not quite suited for expedition-type climbing such as on Denali. Yes, theyre fine on a peak such as Aconcagua, the 22,841-foot mountain in Argentina. And yes, it does get cold on Aconcagua. But Denali is sort of in a league by itself, given its proximity to the Arctic Circle. Especially in May, it gets cold, cold, cold there (-25F and colder on a regular basis). I was there in June several years back and we saw -20F several times at 17,000 feet.
So Im with your guidego with the double boots, and full overboots. Scarpas tried-and-true Inverno ($279) is a good choice, as is the newer and lighter Omega ($375). Also take a look at the Koflach Arctis Expe ($400). Mountain Hardwears Absolute Zero overboot ($100) is a good choice, but Id probably go with the Brooks Ranger from Outdoor Research ($135), as I think they are a little warmer.
So thats my take. Hope you have a good trip!
The 2008 Summer Outside Buyers Guide is now online. From riding to trail-running to camping, get reviews of nearly 400 gear must-haves.