Gear Guy

Gamma SV     Photo: courtesy, Arc'teryx

Q:

Why don't soft shells come standard with a hood?

I'm looking for a warm three-season jacket. I have a hard shell and a TNF Denali for really cold situations. I've been researching the Arc'teryx Gma line and the Mountain Hardwear Synchro as options for a good jacket that can be worn for spring and summer hikes in the Sierras and Rockies. Any suggestions? Also, why do many soft shells not come standard with a hood? Michelle San Diego, California

A:I think a soft shell is a good call for your needs. On a cool spring day you don't usually need that full-on all-weather gear, especially when you're working hard and hiking. Something to block the wind, repel some light moisture, retain some heat—that's the ticket. And that's what the often-confusing "soft-shell" category attempts to deliver: a light jacket that's good enough for 80 percent of the weather conditions we encounter.

Trouble is, there are all sorts of iterations of the species we call soft shell. Mountain Hardwear's Synchro ($220; www.mountainhardwear.com), for instance, performs as a lightly insulated shell, using Mountain Hardwear's proprietary, waterproof-breathable Conduit material as its outer shell, with some fleece on the underside. It's best suited for climates that are apt to be damp as well as cool. Arc'teryx's Gamma SV ($260; www.arcteryx.com), on the other hand, uses Polartec Power Shield—a very water- and wind-repellent material that offers a little more breathability than the Synchro at the expense of a little less rain-resistance.

Personally, I prefer the latter approach. I usually have an idea what my odds of facing rain over the next several hours will be (for day trips, at least) and so can feel safe wearing something that gives me the greatest comfort range—and that's usually a piece similar to the Gamma. You might also look at REI's One Jacket ($179; www.rei.com), which is similar to the Gamma but at a lower price.

Why no hoods? Good question. Part of it is that adding a hood costs money, and these pieces already tend to be pricey because of the high-tech materials. But they're also designed for fairly athletic use, when you might not want to use a hood (or might be using a climbing or biking helmet).

That said, it's not all hoodless soft shells, you know. A close cousin—okay, closer, more like clone—of Arc'teryx's Gamma SV is the Gamma MX Hoody ($350) that has the head/neck cover and longer length favored by skiers and snowboarders. High-end ski-gear purveyor Spyder makes a nice-looking piece called the Jackson Soft Shell ($250; www.spyder.com), complete with hood and lots of those powder-busting seals around the wrists and waist. Salomon and Mountain Hardwear have also gone the hooded soft-shell route for some of their ski-specific stuff, including the Salomon Gore-Tex Softshell Jacket ($440; www.salomonoutdoor.com) and Mountain Hardwear Maneuver ($395; www.mountainhardwear.com). As you'll note, this is where the soft-shell derivation gets murky, as the above pieces all bleed heavily into the trad jacket realm—not to mention a whole new budget bracket!

Myself, I prefer hoodless designs and the use of a hat, which I can pick out depending on the weather, my mood, or my day's chosen activity. In terms of light outdoor pursuits such as day hiking, I regard hoods as sort of "emergency" features...

Get the scoop on more of the industry's best soft shells in Outside Online's all-new Soft-Shell Buying Guide.

Ask a Question!

Our gear experts await your questions. Go ahead, ask them anything.

By submitting above, you agree to the Outside privacy policy. * We might edit your question for length or clarity.

0 Comments

Load More

Comments