I hope you can settle a disagreement between my wife and me. Were going on a five-day trek to Machu Picchu along the Cino Salcantay carrying day packs only. My wife has a pair of 10-year-old Vasque boots that she insists are adequate but don't look very substantial to me. Any suggestion as to what boots she should be wearing on this hike? David Palm City, Florida
Oh, right, like your wife will listen to me and not you? I mean, if she likes them, then why not? Youre not carrying a lot, and youre not going too far about 20 miles, right? They should get her there.
Vasque Ion XCR Mid-Hikers
Ion XCR Mid-Hikers
That said, she might be happier with a newer generation of boot that fits better, offers more comfort, and has better water-proofness. She would probably like a pair of Timberland Cadion Mid GTX boots ($140; timberland.com), for instance. Theyre made on a womens last for a good fit, for one thing. For another, they use Gore-Tex in a liner booty to keep water out and have Schoeller fabric in the uppers for breathability. Very supportive, but comfortable.
Another really great boot is the Scarpa Mustang ($175; scarpa.com). Its a bit heftier than the Timberland, but still very comfortable. And it has a Gore-Tex liner. Its available in a women-specific model.
Lastly, the Vasque Ion XCR Mid-Hikers ($125; vasque.com) have the comfort of a running shoe in a decent trail boot, one that has good toe protection, a Gore-Tex liner, and well-cushioned midsoles. They can go right out of the box with no break-in needed.
So maybe you should leave this page up on her computer and hope she takes the hint. And send us a picture of your wife on the hike!
The 2008 Winter Outside Buyers Guide is now online. From snow sports to trail-running to camping, get reviews of more than 300 new gear must-haves.