Gear Guy

Which Cell Phones Might Replace My GPS Unit?

I'm in the market for a new cell phone that will stand up to some rugged adventuring. Is it possible to find a device that will replace my GPS unit?

Which Cell Phones Might Replace My GPS Unit?

Last time I checked out Bryce Canyon National Park, I dutifully lugged along my colorful, “ruggedized” electronics—a Garmin handheld GPS and a bulky Casio watch with a digital compass. But during the trip I realized that both items are usually made redundant by another piece of electronic gear: that non-ruggedize, urban tool, the cell phone. I use my cell during the work week to set headings between parking lots. Nothing beats the dead-simple practice of following the little blue triangle on your phone. 

Until now, the problem with your phone’s GPS has been its dependency on cellular coverage. Many great hiking areas have a trickle of cellular service. (Only one percent of the land mass of the U.S. has no signal but that’s where they put all the fun mountains.) When you don’t have coverage, the maps don’t load on your phone. Android and Apple screens both show the pulsing triangle in the middle of an empty field. 

On June 27, Google started offering a new feature on Android cell phones: the ability to store a street view map before you leave the house. It goes a long way toward making the Android phone a viable GPS device for hiking. Even with no coverage at all, it gives you the “street” view of the area (sadly a “terrain” view is still not available offline). With a street view, you can judge your location in reference to service roads and labels that mark mountain peaks. (For instance, when I captured Stratton Mountain Ski Area in Vermont, the mountain itself was a flat expanse of green but I could see where I was on the north side.) 

Using your phone is a matter of convenience. Yes, as always, you’ll need to stuff some trusty topo maps in your pack. That’s the same as with a handheld GPS. And if you want better maps you can always pay for specialized topo and hiker-friendly apps in the Apple and Android marketplaces. Apple won’t have offline mapping for the foreseeable future because of its split with Google Maps, and because its iOS 6 (due out in fall 2012) lacks offline mapping, but like its rival, it has plenty of options for apps to buy and install. They typically cost less than $10 for the software and an additional couple of dollars to upload the specific maps you need. In the meantime, handsets with the Windows Phone operating system—admittedly an operating system about as recreation-friendly as a fax machine—will get offline mapping by the end of the year with the introduction of Windows Phone 8. 

The death of the dedicated GPS gadget has been greatly exaggerated. Handheld devices from Garmin, Magellan, and others are still easier to use with more powerful GPS features than the phone apps. In most cases, they are rugged, waterproof, and have much longer battery life. But the old economics of selling the gadgets for a modest price then charging customers more money to upload maps of individual regions is dying. In other words, these manufacturers better catch up, or more hikers, bikers, and outdoors people will have one message for them: Get lost.

The following cell phones and cases are a step in the right direction.

Subscribe to Outside

Outside Magazine Latest Issue

Save 66% and get All-Access: Print + iPad