GearCamping
Q:

Should I buy a mummy or barrel bag for a sea kayaking trip?

I'm setting off on a three-week sea kayaking expedition up the central coast of British Columbia, and I need a synthetic zero-degree (C) to five-degree (C) sleeping bag. But I'm not sure whether to get a mummy bag or a barrel bag. Any recommendations? Guy North Vancouver, British Columbia

A: I agree with your notion that synthetic will be best. I think down’s reputation as an insulation that wets out too easily is a little overblown—particularly given the excellent materials used in sleeping bag shells these days—but three weeks on the water warrants a bit of caution in this regard.

Big Agnes Crystal Sleeping Bag

Big Agnes Crystal


As for the mummy versus barrel (or semi-rectangular, to use the industry’s jargon), it’s all a matter of space and weight. A roomy, semi-rectangular bag is definitely going to be more comfortable, and while that design is less thermally efficient, that’s hardly an issue in this case (for you U.S. citizens, 0 Centigrade is 32 Fahrenheit—in other words, quite mild).

So, which bag? One excellent choice would be Sierra Designs Lazer +30 (U.S. $190; www.sierradesigns.com). It’s a mummy-style bag, but not a real snug one, that uses PrimaLoft Sport as insulation. I like PrimaLoft a lot as it feels softer and more down-like than some of the other synthetics out there, plus it is based on a polyester fiber, a naturally hydrophobic material that sheds water like a duck in the event of a dunking. The Lazer is rated to 30 degrees (F), and in warmer conditions has a zipper at the foot that can be unzipped.

Another good choice would be the Big Agnes Crystal (U.S. $149; www.bigagnes.com). This is a roomy, semi-rectangular bag that’s also rated to 30 degrees (F) and that combines PrimaLoft Sport and 650-fill down. It’s sort of best of both worlds—the softness and light weight of down, with the wet-conditions capability of synthetic.

A third bag I like is Mountain Hardwear’s 1st Dimension 30 (U.S. $155; www.mountainhardwear.com). It’s rated to 30 degrees (F), a popular rating, and uses Polarguard Delta insulation, which I don’t rate quite as highly as PrimaLoft but is a durable, proven material. One excellent feature in the 1st Dimension is that you can unzip a gusset in the bag shell and add eight inches of girth, or zip that closed for more thermal efficiency.

All of these bags weigh in the two-pound range and stuff down to a manageable size, so neither weight nor storage is an issue for a sea kayak trip.

Have fun, and stay safe.

The votes are in: Check out the winners of Outside's 2006 Gear of the Year awards, including the year's hottest (no pun intended) sleeping bag.

Our mission to inspire readers to get outside has never been more critical. In recent years, Outside Online has reported on groundbreaking research linking time in nature to improved mental and physical health, and we’ve kept you informed about the unprecedented threats to America’s public lands. Our rigorous coverage helps spark important debates about wellness and travel and adventure, and it provides readers an accessible gateway to new outdoor passions. Time outside is essential—and we can help you make the most of it. Making a financial contribution to Outside Online only takes a few minutes and will ensure we can continue supplying the trailblazing, informative journalism that readers like you depend on. We hope you’ll support us. Thank you.
Contribute to Outside
Filed To: Sleeping Bags
Lead Photo: courtesy, REI
More Gear