I need a two-person tent that provides plenty of ventilation for fall and spring Southeast backpacking trips, but thats also good for below-tree line trips to the Northeast in winter. I like the Black Diond Skylight, but concerned about how it will hold up to snow. How does the Skylight stack up to other tents in the se weight and roominess categories? Rich Decatur, Georgia
Black Diamond Skylight Tent
Black Diamond Skylight
Here are two issues to consider. One, while it has a lot of mesh around the head of the tent, the Skylight is otherwise solid-body. So on a warm night you might not get much flow-through" venting. Not having used one in warm weather, I cannot tell you whether this really would be a problem. And for winter use, well, single-walls simply arent as warm as traditional canopy-and-fly tents, which can take advantage of a trapped air layer to add a little warmth. Again, under certain conditions that may not be an issue. As for snow, it will hold up as well as any other tentmeaning youll need to kick the snow off if its falling continuously.
The alternative is a traditional convertible" tent such as Marmots very fine Swallow ($360; www.marmot.com). But alas, the Swallow also weighs just over 7 pounds, which makes the Skylight even more appealing. In short, the Skylight offers a very attractive feature set with some very minor drawbacks. So overall, I think its a winner.
The votes are in: Check out the winners of Outside's 2006 Gear of the Year awards, including the Skylight.