I want a kayak that’s light and fast. Should I get a sit-in or a sit-on-top?

Well, yeah, I’m not surprised you have a bit of a struggle keeping up with a tandem Hobie. They have twice the paddling power that you do, in a boat only slightly heavier than a single kayak. Same principle applies in bicycling; there aren’t too many single cyclists who can keep up with a tandem crewed by cyclists of physical ability equal to the single rider. And the Feelfree Move ($545; feelfreekayak.com) is a stubby little thing.

While I have absolutely no quibble with a design such as Hobie’s pedal-powered Mirage Revolution ($1,600; hobiecat.com), I’m doubtful that it would offer any speed advantage over what you’re using now. Likewise, the Cobra Explorer ($460; cobrakayaks.com) is a perfectly fine sit-on-top. But I wonder if you’d be better served by an enclosed kayak. It certainly would be faster—you’re lower in the water, less wind drag, etc. I can imagine that heat would be a factor in your area, but some boats have big, roomy cockpits that vent well.

With that in mind, I’d certainly suggest you take a look at something such as the Necky Manitou ($799; necky.com). It’s a “hybrid" boat, one that you sit inside of like a traditional kayak, but that has more stability and a bigger cockpit. It’s easy to paddle and you don’t feel as if you’re wearing the thing. There’s also a storage compartment for extra gear. I really think you’d find it to be easier to paddle and keep up with your friends. Wilderness Systems Pungo 120 ($775; wildernesssystems.com) is similar, as is the Dagger Blackwater 12 ($679; dagger.com).

You’ve seen our picks for 2007 Gear of the Year, and now the entire Outside Summer Buyer’s Guide is online. Check out this year’s more than 400 must-have gear items, including kayaks.