The Six Most Revealing Comments People Gave to Trump About Bears Ears

Recently released public comments from Utah residents show an overwhelming majority—88 percent—support preserving the monument's status

A family watches the sun set on Bears Ears National Monument. (Photo: Bob Wick/BLM)
A family watches the sun set on Bears Ears National Monument.

Over the past month, more than 150,000 people have offered public comment to the Department of Interior regarding President Trump’s order to review more than 20 of the country’s national monuments. Many wrote directly to Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke to voice their opinions about Bears Ears National Monument in southern Utah, a 1.35-million-acre swath of arid land containing sacred Native American artifacts and striking geological features, which was designated a national monument by President Obama shortly before he left office. The Center for Western Priorities (CWP), a nonpartisan conservation organization, recently compiled comments exclusively from residents of Utah, a population that has much at stake regarding the fate of Bears Ears.

Of the roughly 1,200 self-identified Utahns who commented, 88 percent recommended preserving the Bears Ears National Monument in its current form, while 11 percent argued the monument should be rescinded or significantly reduced in size, says Aaron Weiss, media director at CWP. Despite that overwhelming support for the monument, Secretary Zinke recommended on June 12 that President Trump reduce its size. In light of this news, we compiled some of the most insightful comments—both for and against monument status—from Utah residents.

A veteran with PTSD finds peace in Bears Ears:

I live in La Sal, San Juan County, Utah. From my house I can see the Bears Ears National Monument. I live less than 15 miles from the north boundary. I am in total support of Bears Ears National Monument. Also Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument.

As a Vietnam veteran with post-traumatic stress disorder, I use these areas to find peace, quiet, and solitute [sic]. I find it sad your traveling partners to the Bears Ears National Monument were all people who want to drill, mine and sell these lands. Look up "Lyman Farms" and see what is happening in Utah.

As a San Juan County, Utah resident I want my voice to be heard I want the Bears Ears National Monument. It is, after all, public land that belongs to all Americans, not to locals, or to the State of Utah. Once it is gone, you can't find another.

A mountain biker weighs in on recreation opportunities:

As a mountain biker, outdoor enthusiast, Utah resident, and a citizen co-owner of our country's public lands, I support our existing national monuments. I support high-quality recreation that's managed in lands protected from reckless development and irresponsible resource extraction!

I oppose the repeal of any national monument protections. This sets a bad precedent. These landscapes host high quality recreation on some of our country's most valuable landscapes. National monuments have proven to be popular attractions for tourists and locals alike, substantially contributing to local and regional economies to a much greater extent than the aforementioned resource extraction which permanently devastates both the land and the tourist generated economy.

The San Gabriel Mountains, Fort Ord, and Berryessa Snow Mountain National Monuments in California are three critical landscapes that mountain bikers had ample voice in creating through a public process. Mountain bikers have trail plans under consideration in other national monuments including Browns Canyon in Colorado, Katahdin Woods and Waters in Maine, and Cascade Siskiyou in Oregon. Likewise, cyclists enjoy riding the rural roads in Escalante Grand Staircase of Utah and Canyon of the Ancients Monuments in Colorado.

These opportunities to enjoy our public lands have ALL come from being involved in a public process. Mountain bikers across the nation can visit and aspire to ride these trails in a natural protected environment.

We applaud a public comment period but urge that a public process be incorporated for designating new monuments not used to roll back existing designations.

I support our existing national monuments.

An experienced outdoorswoman advocates for native artifacts:

A Republican says Zinke isn’t listening to both sides:

Dear Secretary Ryan Zinke,

I have listened to both sides of the argument, concerning National Monuments here in Utah, and I believe our representatives are only listening to those wanting to exploit this resource for profit. If these lands are public lands, they are, then it is not just Utahns [sic] that have a say in this issue. The Native Americans who want to preserve these land by making them a National Monument have not been given equal air time in the media.

These are National Monuments for the nation, not just Utah. I cannot imagine missing out on Yellowstone or any National Monument because of short sighted people like those opposing Bear's Ears or Escalante.
I am a Republican, Combat Veteran, and resident of Utah. I want to keep Bear's Ears and Escalante the way President Obama signed them into law.

Bears Ears will strip the Forest Service of resources, create congestion:

A Native American woman wants the monument repealed:

I live in San Juan County UTAH. I'm Native American, my name is Nicole Wells and a tribal member of the Ute Mountain Ute Tribe and of the Zuni Tribe living in the small community of White Mesa, Utah (84511).

I want Bears Ears National Monument RESCINDED.

WE HAVE NO INFRASTRUCTURE to take on the massive amounts of tourist the greedy OUTDOOR RETAILERS pushed on us with the Bears Ears monument designation!!!

ALSO, Bears Ears isn't even funded at all. what does that mean? My kids have to be stacked with enormous debt our country already has to pay these monuments with my hard earned TAX DOLLARS?


Please understand that the land and the people took care of this area LONG LONG LONG, before there was ever a monument.


I just learned that former Interior Secretary Sally Jewell herself was a CEO of a private company, REI, that gains profits off the designations of national monuments all over the country. that would make sense as to why she recommended President Obama to designate Bears Ears National Monument in a very undemocratic process.

On my tribe, big issues that affect all The People are put to a vote. FOR SOME QUESTIONABLE REASON, this issue for the monument never was brought before our eyes to vote on.
It was a very undemocratic process.


Our mission to inspire readers to get outside has never been more critical. In recent years, Outside Online has reported on groundbreaking research linking time in nature to improved mental and physical health, and we’ve kept you informed about the unprecedented threats to America’s public lands. Our rigorous coverage helps spark important debates about wellness and travel and adventure, and it provides readers an accessible gateway to new outdoor passions. Time outside is essential—and we can help you make the most of it. Making a financial contribution to Outside Online only takes a few minutes and will ensure we can continue supplying the trailblazing, informative journalism that readers like you depend on. We hope you’ll support us. Thank you.
Contribute to Outside
Filed To: UtahPublic LandsPolitics
Lead Photo: Bob Wick/BLM
More Adventure