Everything you need to know to combat social media trolls
When your social media account attracts a storm of negative comments, what’s the best way to respond? Brands, experts, and influencers weigh in.
Get full access to Outside Learn, our online education hub featuring in-depth fitness, nutrition, and adventure courses and more than 2,000 instructional videos when you sign up for Outside+.
“Ping. Ping, ping, ping.” The notifications nagged until Naomi Grevemberg leaned over to find out exactly why her phone was blowing up at 8 p.m. on a Thursday—and felt her heart drop.
Grevemberg is the founder of two platforms for BIPOC and underrepresented folx in the nomadic community: @diversify.vanlife on Instagram, and the podcast Nomads at the Intersections. The former had been trolled: Commenters were lashing out with unfounded complaints that Grevemberg’s BIPOC-centered platforms were alienating white vanlifers.
Comments like these keep social media managers up at night, especially since trolling can quickly transform into an all-out cancel culture campaign.
In my decade of experience as a brand and inclusivity consultant for both startups and Fortune 100 companies, I’ve learned that when trolls attack brands (and people), their violence-driven narrative creates an unsafe space for other followers. This can render even the best social campaigns ineffective or even counterproductive. But trolls are a part of today’s media and marketing landscape. As such, it’s essential to learn to cope with them.
Tip #1: Remember that conversation can be beneficial. Engagement is a top priority for the algorithms that drive all social platforms, says Amanda Baida, owner of digital marketing firm InnerSocial Marketing. Responding to comments, even negative ones, can increase your reach. Plus, not all negative comments constitute trolling. In fact, most comments deserve a response, Baida says.
Tip #2: The trick is to respond the right way. Consider your brand’s style and voice, and how it usually manages public criticism.
“When posting about social justice issues that matter to us, we get hundreds of comments,” says Mare Ruland, “gratitude consultant” for technical pee cloth brand Kula Cloth. “But a brand can [decide] what type of energy it wants to create in its social media spaces. And we choose to make our page a safe space [for our followers and fans].”
For example, when Kula published a post calling attention to gun violence in America, the post was “trolled by right-wing, pro-gun men,” Ruland says. The team chose to immediately delete those comments.
Tip #3: Brands should also create an action plan before trolling events occur. Baida recommends outlining policies for different categories of comments, including harassment, threats, customer complaints, and praise. Predetermined policies can help social media managers frame responses quickly and calmly in a crisis.
Tip #4: Unless comments turn to name-calling, don’t delete them, says Kaya Lindsay, social media manager of stewardship organization Yosemite Facelift and a former assistant social media manager for Access Fund. This can signal that your brand is afraid to face hard topics head-on.
Tip #5: Instead, “Respond clearly and directly without any nuance. Do not engage with other commenters unless they bring up additional information that hasn’t been addressed,” Lindsay recommends. To defuse a situation, she likes to answer questions in a neutral tone, reducing the likelihood for continued aggression by the troll. Baida says it’s also good practice for a brand to direct commenters to another resource on its website, such as an FAQ page, company policy, or blog when appropriate.
Tip #6: And if the comments continue? It could be time for decisive action. Grevemberg, of @diversity.vanlife, regularly faces those kinds of persistent trolls, including overtly racist ones.
“When comments become abusive or violent—i.e. name-calling, racial slurs, threats, etc.—it’s evident that positive, open dialogue is impossible,” Grevemberg says. “That’s when I delete the offending comments and/or block the commenter.” As for the case of the white vanlifer troll? She did just that.
This story first appeared in the Summer 2021 issue of our print magazine.