Big Agnes Crystal Sleeping Bag
Big Agnes Crystal (courtesy, REI)

Should I buy a mummy or barrel bag for a sea kayaking trip?

I'm setting off on a three-week sea kayaking expedition up the central coast of British Columbia, and I need a synthetic zero-degree (C) to five-degree (C) sleeping bag. But I'm not sure whether to get a mummy bag or a barrel bag. Any recommendations? Guy North Vancouver, British Columbia

Big Agnes Crystal Sleeping Bag

Get access to everything we publish when you sign up for Outside+.

I agree with your notion that synthetic will be best. I think down’s reputation as an insulation that wets out too easily is a little overblown—particularly given the excellent materials used in sleeping bag shells these days—but three weeks on the water warrants a bit of caution in this regard.

Big Agnes Crystal Sleeping Bag

Big Agnes Crystal Sleeping Bag Big Agnes Crystal

As for the mummy versus barrel (or semi-rectangular, to use the industry’s jargon), it’s all a matter of space and weight. A roomy, semi-rectangular bag is definitely going to be more comfortable, and while that design is less thermally efficient, that’s hardly an issue in this case (for you U.S. citizens, 0 Centigrade is 32 Fahrenheit—in other words, quite mild).

So, which bag? One excellent choice would be Sierra Designs Lazer +30 (U.S. $190; It’s a mummy-style bag, but not a real snug one, that uses PrimaLoft Sport as insulation. I like PrimaLoft a lot as it feels softer and more down-like than some of the other synthetics out there, plus it is based on a polyester fiber, a naturally hydrophobic material that sheds water like a duck in the event of a dunking. The Lazer is rated to 30 degrees (F), and in warmer conditions has a zipper at the foot that can be unzipped.

Another good choice would be the Big Agnes Crystal (U.S. $149; This is a roomy, semi-rectangular bag that’s also rated to 30 degrees (F) and that combines PrimaLoft Sport and 650-fill down. It’s sort of best of both worlds—the softness and light weight of down, with the wet-conditions capability of synthetic.

A third bag I like is Mountain Hardwear’s 1st Dimension 30 (U.S. $155; It’s rated to 30 degrees (F), a popular rating, and uses Polarguard Delta insulation, which I don’t rate quite as highly as PrimaLoft but is a durable, proven material. One excellent feature in the 1st Dimension is that you can unzip a gusset in the bag shell and add eight inches of girth, or zip that closed for more thermal efficiency.

All of these bags weigh in the two-pound range and stuff down to a manageable size, so neither weight nor storage is an issue for a sea kayak trip.

Have fun, and stay safe.

The votes are in: Check out the winners of Outside‘s 2006 Gear of the Year awards, including the year’s hottest (no pun intended) sleeping bag.

From Outside Magazine, April/May 2021
Filed to:
Lead Photo: courtesy, REI