Who makes the best sleeping bags in the biz?
Oh Gear Guy, please open my eyes and show me who makes the best bags in the biz. Is it Western Mountaineering or Feathered Friends? I'm further confused with reports of two other excellent manufacturers, Integral Designs and newcomer Valandré. David Los Angeles, California
Going to punt on this one: All the manufacturers you mention make superb bags, although each puts its own spin on things. I’m a long-time Feathered Friends user, and I think that company’s Swallow ($320 with Quantum Pertex shell; www.featheredfriends.com) is the classic 20-degree down bag. Then again, Western’s Badger Super MF ($380; www.westernmountaineering.com) is an unbelievable 15-degree bagroomy, yet still only two pounds, eight ounces.
With Integral Designs and Valandré (a French company that is a relative newcomer to the U.S. market) you get into real semi-custom bag territory. In the all-mountain category, Integral Designs offers the XPD00 Appalachian bag ($370 and up, depending on options; www.integraldesigns.com), a high-quality bag roughly analogous to the Swallow. Valandré’s deal is the incredible precision with which the bags are made, resulting in a bag that “fits” like no other. For cold weather, check out the Shocking Blue ($695; www.valandre.com), rated to minus 13 but capable of going much lower. An incredibly beautiful, well-made bag.
In short, none of these gear makers’ bags will let you down. It’s a matter of price, style, temp rating, and fit. And keep in mind the bag in my gear loft that’s gotten the most use in recent years isn’t by any of these folks. It’s a light Marmot bag in a model that’s no longer made. Rated to 32 degrees, weighs about 20 ounces. Check out Marmot’s new-edition Hydrogen, complete with a 30-degree rating and weighing in at one pound, five ounces ($309; www.marmot.com).
For the ultimate sleeping-bag encyclopedia, check out Outside Online’s all-new Sleeping-Bag Buying Guide.