Thule Moab Basket
Thule Moab Basket

Factory or aftermarket roof rack?

I'm putting a ski/bike rack on my new Subaru, and I'm wondering what to get: Thule, Yakima, or factory?

Thule Moab Basket

Outside's long reads email newsletter features our strongest writing, most ambitious reporting, and award-winning storytelling about the outdoors. Sign up today.

What would a Subaru be without a roof rack? Those cars were purpose built to carry skis, bikes, and maybe the occasional kayak.

Yakima Loadwarrior basket

Yakima Loadwarrior basket Yakima Loadwarrior basket

Yakima Fatcat 4

Yakima Fatcat 4 Yakima Fatcat 4

Yakima Sprocketrocket

Yakima Sprocketrocket Yakima Sprocketrocket

I wouldn’t recommend buying a factory rack, though, at least not for the actual carrying pieces—they’re overpriced. Factory bars are fine, and you can easily attach aftermarket accessories to them. I mounted my Yakima Loadwarrior car-top basket ($269) to the factory bars on my 2005 WRX. I chose the Loadwarrior for its versatility: the basket can carry any type of cargo, and it fits both Yakima’s Fatcat 4 ski attachment ($209) and the company’s SprocketRocket bike holder ($189).

Although both Yakima and Thule would disagree, I don’t see many qualitative difference between the companies. Which you choose really comes down to aesthetics and whether there’s a specific setup you want. Thule offers a similar arrangement to the one I have with their 690XT M.O.A.B. basket ($379), a Universal Flat Top ($170) for skis, and a 513 Domestique ($170) for bikes. And, of course, with either Yakima or Thule you can always do without the basket and attach the carriers directly to the factory cross pieces.

—Doug Gantenbein

Filed to:

promo logo