Gear Guy

What soft shell will economize on budget and weight?

Lieber Ausrüstungmensch: Looking at the change of seasons and your report on the latest and greatest in the gear world, I'm trying to come up with a clothing strategy that maximizes economy of budget and weight. I'm a keen hiker currently living in Germany (near the Alps), but who will be moving back to the East Coast of the U.S. (Smoky Mountains!) soon. I want a system that will cover me when it's warm, cool, and wet. Should I go with a fleece-plus-shell combo, lugging around the deadweight when I'm not using it, or should I buy one of the do-it-all soft shells? Patrick Frankfurt Main, Germany


For exclusive access to all of our fitness, gear, adventure, and travel stories, plus discounts on trips, events, and gear, sign up for Outside+ today.

Guten Tag! Wie geht es Ihnen?

OK, enough of my bilingual dexterity. You need some outdoor clothing. Here’s how I see it: For years, people tended to pack two key pieces, a moderately heavy fleece jacket or sweater, and a substantial Gore-Tex (or similar) jacket or parka. That was, and still is, a combination that pretty much covers the gamut of weather conditions: wet, cold, mild, windy, in any combination.

But I’m not convinced all that stuff remains necessary. The great appeal of the new “soft-shell” jackets is that they handle the cool, windy stuff nicely by themselves, plus they shed drizzle or light rain that would otherwise have soaked a fleece jacket. Then, if it gets really wet, you can just fling on a light rain shell. For less weight, bulk, and money, the soft shell route gives you a very functional weather package.

So for the soft-shell part, you want something that offers pretty good insulation and isn’t just a light shell (which some are). Examples: the REI One Jacket ($198;, made with Polartec Power Shield, a material I rate having used it in a cycling jacket. In cold weather, the One is remarkably warm when worn over a light, long-sleeve T-shirt or turtleneck. It’s almost entirely windproof, breathes well, and can take a lot of rain before it soaks through. Arc’Teryx’s Gamma SV ($250; uses the same material in a garment that’s a little more trimly cut. Cloudveil’s Serendipity ($220; works a bit more like a light shell, but also serves as a useful insulating mid-layer (over a light T-shirt, under a rain shell if it rains hard).

These days, the classic add-on to a soft shell is the Marmot PreCip Jacket ($99;, a remarkable buy in a functional, light, compressible rainjacket. Lowe Alpine’s Rush Tech Jacket ($109; is another good choice. Depending on the activity, I also like Pearl Izumi’s Channel Jacket ($200;, which uses the new eVent waterproof-breathable fabric favored by some makers. The Channel is a slim, clean (i.e., no pockets and no hood) design that is great unless you really need to stuff things into pockets. I prefer a rainhat, anyway, so the lack of a hood is no hardship.

Hope that helps. Auf Wiedersehn!

promo logo