For a lot of people, myself included, ankle braces are indeed necessary. And I dont mean a light, elastic-type wrap. Im talking about the ballistic-nylon, wrap-around, lace-up models that sell for $30 to $40 (such as the ASO Ankle Brace). If you have a balky ankle, its the only thing that will hold it in place. Not even heavy boots really help that much.
Certainly, a brace takes a lot of strain off your ankle, so I suppose one answer to your question about dependency is, Yes, wearing a brace can reduce your ankles ability to strengthen itself naturally." But thats also not the worst thing in the world. The brace reduces the risk of re-injury, and every time you roll over on your ankle, you reduce the tendons ability to recover. Meanwhile, in consultation with a credible sourcesuch as your orthopedist or physical therapist, and not someone like, um, meyou embark on a rigorous in-house or in-gym strengthening program.
My bad ankle is the right one, so thats where the brace goes. Ive never had a problem with the left ankle, so theres no brace there. An ASO brace fits pretty nicely under nearly any footwear; Ive worn my very similar brace with probably 15 different boots, from day hikers to plastic mountaineering boots. Theyre made from neoprene and nylon, dry reasonably quickly, and are washable.
So go forth, well-braced, and enjoy the world!
The 2008 Summer Outside Buyers Guide is now online. From riding to trail-running to camping, get reviews of nearly 400 gear must-haves.