Gear Guy


Do hydration packs optimize the body's water intake?

I guess this might be more of a biological or physiological question than a straight gear question, but I notice that when I sip water from a CelBak, I have to "go" less than if I take bigger yet less frequent gulps from a water bottle. It seems that even drinking a full 70 ounces from my CelBak, compared to a quart from a bottle, is easier on my bladder. I just imagining this? Does the body better optimize water that's sipped slowly? Bill Bedford, New Hampshire

A: The answer to this seeming conundrum has several permutations. First, as you note, CamelBak hydration packs lend themselves more to sipping, while water bottles probably do elicit more of a "gulping" reflex. So my bet is that in most cases you're actually drinking more in a shorter space of time from the bottle than the CamelBak.

It's possible, too, that something else is going on: You're working harder on CamelBak trips for some reason, so you sweat more and have less left to dump into your bladder. Otherwise, I'm skeptical of the notion that you make "better use" of sipped water. It's true that your kidneys will respond to large amounts of water by sending more to the bladder. But short of pounding down a quart or two at a time (most stomachs have a four-cup capacity, more or less), your body is very good at making use of any water it gets, depending on its need.

Anyway, it's an interesting scientific question. Maybe you can figure out a way to test this by monitoring your fluid intake for 24 hours as a control, then on subsequent Saturdays take the same hike at the same temperature and humidity, using a CamelBak one day, a water bottle another. Drink the same amount of water from each. Then pee into a cup and measure. There may be a Nobel in it for you!

Subscribe to Outside

Outside Magazine Latest Issue

Subscribe Now and Save 75%!

Big. Crazy. Opinionated.

Thank you!