Can I hike with trail runners instead of full-on boots?

I having a very tough time finding hiking boots that are comfortable; they all seem to hurt somewhere. I did find a pair of comfortable trail runners, and I'm wondering if I'd have any trouble day hiking in Glacier National Park using these instead of hiking boots or shoes? How much of a difference is there? Laura Jefferson City, Missouri

For exclusive access to all of our fitness, gear, adventure, and travel stories, plus discounts on trips, events, and gear, sign up for Outside+ today.

Sure, you can use trail runners for day hikes in Glacier National Park. You’ll be somewhat restricted to trails or dry cross-country routes, but they’ll work fine. Actually, lots of people use trail runners for exactly this purpose. In women’s shoes, the Asics Eagle Trail ($90; has lots of cushioning and a grippy sole for trail work. Merrell’s Reflex ($85; is built more like a very light hiker, as is Montrail’s Kinabalu ($100;, a new shoe, and a really good-looking one at that.

That said, I’m a little surprised you can’t find a comfortable hiking shoe, unless you’re one of these people who takes a size 14EEE and wonders why no one makes hiking boots that fit them. I can suggest three boots that are renowned for both comfort and fit. One is the Asolo FSN 95 GTX ($150; This shoe appeared in 2001 to wild acclaim—it has the support of a midweight hiker, but feels more like a solid trail runner. Very comfortable. L.L. Bean’s Cresta Leather Hiker ($169; seems to fit nearly everyone—it’s available in widths and on a women’s last and is an extremely capable all-around midweight boot. Lastly, Montrail’s Sandia Peak ($120) is a light, women-specific trail boot—it doesn’t even appear in men’s sizes.

There are several advantages of a hiking boot over trail runners: better support, better protection from rocks and sticks, and better weather and water resistance. They weigh a little more, true, but the above models all are admirably light.

Have a good trip! I’ll be in Glacier in September on a bike tour.

promo logo