Does anything beat deet to repel bloodsucking insects?
I do most of my backpacking when the bugs (mainly mosquitoes) are out. Last year, CNN said that there were two alternatives to deet, including lemon eucalyptus. But is there anything that comes close to deet's performance, without the plastic-destroying quality? Chuck Mount Morris, Michigan
Receive $50 off an eligible $100 purchase at the Outside Shop, where you’ll find a selection of brand-name products curated by our gear editors, when you sign up for Outside+ today.
Deetderived as an acronym for di-ethyl-toluamidewas developed in the 1950s and remains the world’s most effective bug repellent. In most cases it’s reasonably safe, provided you don’t pickle yourself in high concentrations of the stuff. Caution is advised for children, however (10 percent dilutions or less; repellent applied to clothing rather than skin). And deet has well-documented solvent qualities that can be hard on plastics and similar materials.
A lot of people tout alternatives based on soybeans or citrus. Some are moderately effective. But none works as well as deet nor lasts as long. Now, however, there are some effective alternatives. For years, a repellent called Picaridin (pee-CAR-ee-den) has been available in Asia and Europe. Tests show that it works more or less as well as deet (maybe even better in some cases), poses no risk to adults or children, doesn’t cause plastic to melt, and is generally much more pleasant. Picaridin was made available in the U.S. market last summer in Cutter Advanced bug juice ($6 for a six-ounce bottle; www.cutterinsectrepellent.com).
S.C. Johnson, the makers of the popular, deet-based Off! repellents, also markets a Picaridin product (which the Johnson folks call Picaridin Autan). It goes by Skintastic CleanFeel, and contains 5 percent Picaridin (the Cutter is 7 percent). Sells for $5 for a six-ounce bottle.
I’d like to hear some feedback on these things from people in bug-intensive states. At least one competitor claims Picaridin doesn’t work. And what with the threat of West Nile virus and all, bug repellents have become serious stuff, not just a way to deter a moderate nuisance.