Gear Guy

What’s the most durable set of bike pedals?

I have just purchased a new road-racing bicycle and now searching the market for some pedals. As you know, pedals are extras on most models, but what to buy: Time, Look, Shimano, Cpagnolo? The choice is a little overwhelming. Do you have any suggestions on some good, reliable pedals that will last and not cost a fortune? Weight's not an issue, nor is the latest, greatest technology. Wayne Luleå, Sweden

For exclusive access to all of our fitness, gear, adventure, and travel stories, plus discounts on trips, events, and gear, sign up for Outside+ today.

Pedals can indeed cause a web of confusion: different brands, different weights, single-sided versus double-sided, the choices go on.

My first consideration is always the single- or double-sided issue. How will you be using the bike? For my rain/night bike, for instance, I go with Shimano’s SPD double-sided pedals to facilitate no-look (or no-see) clip-in. My mountain bike has double-sided Time ATACs for the same reason (plus the ATACs shed mud well). My “fast” road bike, on the other hand, has single-sided pedals from Look. In part, I guess I’m just going along with convention—after all, pros all ride with single-sided pedals. But, such pedals usually have a bigger contact area, so can be slightly more comfortable on long rides. I don’t agonize too much over weight; I want security and comfort first, with weight a secondary consideration.

As a general rule, pedal specialists tend to be more popular than pedals offered as part of a “gruppo” (i.e., Shimano pedals with Shimano components). Look and Time have been the market leaders for a long time. Both make excellent, sturdy pedals that are slightly heavy but comfortable and extremely secure. Time has introduced a redesigned pedal called the Impact, which comes in several models, starting at $180 ( It has a low-profile design (meaning you don’t have a lot of cleat between you and the pedal) and you can adjust that distance, called the Q-factor, if you wish. It also has adjustable release angle and pedal float. Look invented the clipless pedal in 1984 and still makes great ones. I like their streamlined design, plus the big, very secure pedal cleat. The new A5.1 ($170; is a great mid-range pedal. Shimano’s Ultegra pedal ($130; is another good one, although I’d first get a Look or Time pedal.

promo logo