Gear Guy

Are pricier base layers worth the extra cash?

Gear Guru: I work out almost every day, so I need a lot of base-layer garments. When it's not too cold out, my CoolMax Alta turtlenecks seem a good deal. But what about the other, pricier options? Do these have wondrous additional capabilities worth the extra cash? David Portland, Oregon

Heading out the door? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Download the app.

CoolMax, a fabric developed by DuPont, is one of the best all-around performance fabrics out there. It works well, plus it’s relatively inexpensive because DuPont lets a variety of manufacturers use the stuff, which fosters competition. I have a slew of CoolMax T-shirts I use as both summer and winter base layers, and for which I paid about $10 a pop at Campmor.

But, that said, there are other good choices available. I’m a huge fan of Patagonia’s Capilene, both the “regular” weight (like their Capilene Lightweight T-shirt: $29; and the super-soft silkweight (Capilene Silkweight T-shirt, $32). The silkweight fabric is especially good at wicking. And it’s astonishingly warm when worn under a wind shell. I was climbing Mount Rainier a few weeks ago, for instance, and inadvertently packed two mid-weight long-sleeve T-shirts, thinking one was a pair of bottoms. That left me with only a silkweight bottom, plus Gore-Tex pants. Despite the fact it was cold and windy, I fared pretty well.

I also really, really like Polartec stuff, both their Power Dry and Power Stretch, which have similar wicking properties but differ in their “stretchiness.” They’re a little warmer than CoolMax or silkweight Capilene and make excellent base layers, albeit moderately expensive. REI sells a Power Dry Zip T-Neck, long sleeve, for $38. That would be a great piece for winter running in Portland (where I once trained for marathons), when worn under a light shell.

So there you go. Your CoolMax is great, but there are other good choices.